HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Don’t Jail Trump for January 6

Views:1033
@ReasonVids

As the latest testimony at the January 6 committee hearings makes clear, there is no doubt that former President Donald Trump is morally responsible for the attack on the U.S. Capitol.
---------
https://reason.com/?posttype=video&p=8194521

But there's a big difference between being morally responsible and being criminally liable, and anyone who thinks this is going to end with Trump being prosecuted for incitement, and then going to prison, desperately needs a reality check.

Eyewitness testimony from the January 6 hearings earlier this week does show that Trump wanted his supporters to march to the Capitol. "I will be making a Big Speech at 10AM on January 6th at the Ellipse (South of the White House)," he wrote in a draft tweet that was never sent "Please arrive early, massive crowds expected. March to the Capitol after. Stop the Steal!!"

On December 19, he tweeted: "​Big protest in D.C. on January 6th. Be there, will be wild!"

During his actual speech just before the attack, Trump told his supporters to "fight like hell" and to march to the Capitol "peacefully and patriotically." Shortly after, the protests got out of hand, and some members of the crowd smashed the windows of the Capitol, pushed past police, and invaded the building.

It's fair to hold Trump responsible for that; if he had not stoked the mob's anger by falsely claiming, repeatedly, that Democrats were stealing the election from him, there would have been no riot.

But do Trump's actions meet the legal definition of incitement to violence? No.

Under federal law, incitement is defined as "urging or instigating other persons to riot." The landmark 1969 Supreme Court case Brandenburg v. Ohio established that speech must be both likely to incite "imminent lawless action" and "directed" at achieving that result.

Trump's words inspired lawless action but didn't specifically call on the mob to engage in it. Asking his supporters to march to the Capitol is protected by the First Amendment.

Now some media commentators have said that recent testimony from Cassidy Hutchinson, a former White House aide, changes the equation: She said under oath that Trump knew that some of the protesters were armed with weapons, and didn't seem to care.

But that isn't legally relevant. People don't lose their First and Second Amendment rights just because they're exercising them at the same time.

We should be glad that these rights are protected by the Constitution. You may not like Trump. Personally, I think he's unfit for office. But we don't want to live in a country where people can be sent to jail because they said the wrong thing. Everybody benefits from a legal regime in which the rights to speak, to protest, and to be armed are vigorously protected.

So let's not send Trump to jail. Let's just never send him back to the White House.

Written and produced by Robby Soave; edited by Regan Taylor.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
    Thumbnail for Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)2:33
    Great Moments in Unintended Consequences (Vol. 8)
    ReasonVids
    1054 views
    Thumbnail for Policing for Profit? California Towns Bill Residents Thousands for Nuisance Violations7:52
    Policing for Profit? California Towns Bill Residents Thousands for Nuisance Violations
    ReasonVids
    1112 views
    Thumbnail for Never Enough: William Voegeli on America's Limitless Welfare State8:11
    Never Enough: William Voegeli on America's Limitless Welfare State
    ReasonVids
    918 views
    Thumbnail for Trucker hunts guy down and forces him off the road after honked at him for drifting into lane. When that didn’t work, he attacks with a hammer. Skip to 1:407:00
    Trucker hunts guy down and forces him off the road after honked at him for drifting into lane. When that didn’t work, he attacks with a hammer. Skip to 1:40
    bestofupgoat
    234 views
    Thumbnail for National Committee Chair Nicholas Sarwark on the Libertarian Party's Plan for 20168:52
    National Committee Chair Nicholas Sarwark on the Libertarian Party's Plan for 2016
    ReasonVids
    947 views
    Thumbnail for How Obama's War on Drugs Destroys Legal Immigrant Families4:25
    How Obama's War on Drugs Destroys Legal Immigrant Families
    ReasonVids
    888 views
    Thumbnail for Drew Drechsel at Stage 1 of American Ninja Warrior USA vs. The World 2015 | American Ninja Warrior2:00
    Drew Drechsel at Stage 1 of American Ninja Warrior USA vs. The World 2015 | American Ninja Warrior
    ninjawarrior
    1186 views
    Thumbnail for I wouldn't go to France0:56
    I wouldn't go to France
    bestofupgoat
    364 views
    Thumbnail for Porker of The Month (July 2010): Rep. Marcy Kaptur!1:28
    Porker of The Month (July 2010): Rep. Marcy Kaptur!
    ReasonVids
    893 views
    Thumbnail for Just take your damn vax, goy! 0:09
    Just take your damn vax, goy!
    bestofvoatxyz
    677 views
    Thumbnail for Nigger nigs out, sets off huge pile of fireworks indoors 1:21
    Nigger nigs out, sets off huge pile of fireworks indoors
    bestofupgoat
    241 views
    Thumbnail for Granny Telling the "Truth" About The Holohoax2:12
    Granny Telling the "Truth" About The Holohoax
    bestoftalk.lol
    967 views
    Thumbnail for The Mystery of the Missing Baby Formula4:07
    The Mystery of the Missing Baby Formula
    ReasonVids
    1002 views
    Thumbnail for Citizen vs. Government (Vol. 6)1:03
    Citizen vs. Government (Vol. 6)
    ReasonVids
    889 views
    Thumbnail for So I tried upgrading the Warden's sonic boom. | hoovLine0:06
    So I tried upgrading the Warden's sonic boom. | hoovLine
    invidious
    384 views
    Thumbnail for The Reason This TV Show Ended... | cardogjones0:21
    The Reason This TV Show Ended... | cardogjones
    invidious
    122 views
    Thumbnail for Jon Haidt on The Coddling of the American Mind and How We Should Address It25:48
    Jon Haidt on The Coddling of the American Mind and How We Should Address It
    ReasonVids
    929 views
    Thumbnail for Moral Markets: Paul Zak discusses Oxytocin, Trade, and Human Nature14:17
    Moral Markets: Paul Zak discusses Oxytocin, Trade, and Human Nature
    ReasonVids
    863 views
    Thumbnail for Indiana Lawmakers Surprised To Learn They Banned Driving With Cell Phones1:29
    Indiana Lawmakers Surprised To Learn They Banned Driving With Cell Phones
    ReasonVids
    922 views
    Thumbnail for Boil in human excrement 1:17
    Boil in human excrement
    bestofupgoat
    137 views
    Thumbnail for  Graham Linehan says he won’t work with Channel 4 again unless transphobic IT Crowd episode is reinstated2:50
    Graham Linehan says he won’t work with Channel 4 again unless transphobic IT Crowd episode is reinstated
    bestofphuks
    2182 views
    Thumbnail for Doom II: Sunlust - MAP03: Forgotten Shrine (Ultra-Violence 100%) | decino24:50
    Doom II: Sunlust - MAP03: Forgotten Shrine (Ultra-Violence 100%) | decino
    doom.topic
    422 views
    Thumbnail for Beijing Biden's Big Red Army of Soy | Ride and Roast42:45
    Beijing Biden's Big Red Army of Soy | Ride and Roast
    Terrence Popp
    1519 views
    Thumbnail for Professor NoWhiteGuilt explains his position that anti-semitism/removing jews wouldnt cause whites to care about themselves or save the white race0:57
    Professor NoWhiteGuilt explains his position that anti-semitism/removing jews wouldnt cause whites to care about themselves or save the white race
    bestofupgoat
    424 views
    Thumbnail for The First Presidential Debate in 3 Minutes3:17
    The First Presidential Debate in 3 Minutes
    ReasonVids
    916 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle