HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

The Trump Tax Plan Is Government as Usual

Views:865
@ReasonVids

Donald Trump has declared "with tax reform, we can make it morning in America again" and that "revising our tax code is not just a policy discussion — it is a moral one, because we are not talking about the government's money – we are talking about your money, your hard work."

The Republican tax plan, which would cut rates for individuals and small businesses, sounds like good policy, but it's not. Before we get lost in details and political infighting, it's worth laying out what effective tax reform actually looks like.


Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv

Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.


The hallmark of a good tax code is that it doesn't attempt social engineering via revenue collection.. It's our money and the government shouldn't be telling us how to spend it or what to spend it on. And yet our tax code is larded up with all sorts of incentives for certain types of purchases—such as the mortgage-interest deduction, which is defended on the grounds that owning a home is morally and culturally superior to renting. It's not by the way, and the result is market distortions that saddle families that would be better off renting with mortgage debt. Trump's tax plan keeps the mortgage interest rate deduction--and the one for charitable giving, which is another example of social engineering.

Another distortion in the tax code is that individuals can deduct the cost of their state and local taxes from their federal bill, effectively allowing jurisdictions like New York and California to get away with charging their residents more than they would otherwise. To its credit, the Trump plan at least attempts to do away with this practice, although it's doubtful this idea will survive the legislative process..

The most important principle for tax reform is that revenue should cover the actual costs of government so that citizens can actually make an informed decision about what services they're willing to pay for. On this score, Trump's plan is sadly business as usual.

First, it would take even more people off the tax rolls. There are already over 40 million households that pay no federal income tax at all and the president brags that his plan would add another 31 million to that total. As Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute writes, "taking more people off the tax rolls is not a good way to keep the government limited. If something is 'free,' people will demand more of it."

And the problem is much bigger than that. For decades now, the feds have been spending far more in any given year than they take in via taxes. Last year, for instance, the government spent 20 percent more than it took in and between 2009 and 2013, it spent 33 percent more than it brought in. Hence annual deficits and ballooning national debt. This is like government by Groupon: Every year, we're getting such a great deal, of course we want more and more stuff. We'd be stupid not to.

Where does Trump's plan land on this topic?

Who knows?

Every tax reform promises to either be revenue neutral or to increase the government's haul. In many cases, neither outcome is close to being truthful. More to the point, after years of accumulating debt we need to focus on government spending first and foremost. In 2016, the feds took in about $3 trillion in taxes. That should be the absolute spending limit—instead of the nearly $4 trillion Congress is talking about.

Taxes aren't the price we pay for civilization—they're the price we pay for government. And until we bind the two together, we'll be spending more and more money that we don't have on things we almost certainly wouldn't want if we had to pay full price for them.

Produced by Todd Krainin. Written and narrated by Nick Gillespie. Cameras by Jim Epstein.

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
paul ryan
,
joe biden
,
tax reform
,
tax code
,
reagan
,
jobs
,
mitch mcconnell
Thumbnail for Bitcoin and the Blockchain Will Stomp Out Wall Street Fraud34:53
Bitcoin and the Blockchain Will Stomp Out Wall Street Fraud
ReasonVids
944 views
Thumbnail for Another Sign of the Pole Shift 3:26
Another Sign of the Pole Shift
AOUisgay
523 views
Thumbnail for 'Medicare Is a Bank Without Security Guards:' Media Exec David Goldhill vs. Princeton's Paul Starr1:21:45
'Medicare Is a Bank Without Security Guards:' Media Exec David Goldhill vs. Princeton's Paul Starr
ReasonVids
814 views
Thumbnail for The Reawakening of the Black Gun-Rights Movement9:21
The Reawakening of the Black Gun-Rights Movement
ReasonVids
948 views
Thumbnail for Ralphie May talks about gay people 20 years ago1:53
Ralphie May talks about gay people 20 years ago
bestofvoatxyz
585 views
Thumbnail for Poll workers opening ballots, looking at who the vote was for, and throwing them straight in the trash0:26
Poll workers opening ballots, looking at who the vote was for, and throwing them straight in the trash
AOU
1368 views
Thumbnail for Ajit Pawar Indapur Sabha LIVE: दत्ता भरणेंसाठी दादांची सभा, हर्षवर्धन पाटलांवर काय निशाणा? | Mumbai Tak1:56:59
Ajit Pawar Indapur Sabha LIVE: दत्ता भरणेंसाठी दादांची सभा, हर्षवर्धन पाटलांवर काय निशाणा? | Mumbai Tak
invidious
156 views
Thumbnail for  Dr. Simone Gold - The truth about the CV-19 Vaccine56:08
Dr. Simone Gold - The truth about the CV-19 Vaccine
AOU
1145 views
Thumbnail for The Growing Libertarian Youth Movement: Q&A with SFL's Alexander McCobin and Blayne Bennett2:16
The Growing Libertarian Youth Movement: Q&A with SFL's Alexander McCobin and Blayne Bennett
ReasonVids
913 views
Thumbnail for Ethnic cat0:15
Ethnic cat
AmericanMuskrat
258 views
Thumbnail for Rand Paul: Lindsey Graham "doesn't rise beyond middle school kind of rhetoric"1:37
Rand Paul: Lindsey Graham "doesn't rise beyond middle school kind of rhetoric"
ReasonVids
900 views
Thumbnail for The Rings Of Power - Here We Go Again6:59
The Rings Of Power - Here We Go Again
bestofupgoat
272 views
Thumbnail for Ayn Rand & The World She Made: Q&A with Anne Heller6:33
Ayn Rand & The World She Made: Q&A with Anne Heller
ReasonVids
992 views
Thumbnail for Abe Simpson - Union Buster0:55
Abe Simpson - Union Buster
clips
1144 views
Thumbnail for IMPUGNED.COM1:47
IMPUGNED.COM
bestofupgoat
141 views
Thumbnail for Timothy McVeigh DINDU NUFFIN!2:50
Timothy McVeigh DINDU NUFFIN!
bestofupgoat
119 views
Thumbnail for Gov. Gary Johnson: Cut Spending by 43% - and Cut Social Issues from GOP Agenda3:53
Gov. Gary Johnson: Cut Spending by 43% - and Cut Social Issues from GOP Agenda
ReasonVids
963 views
Thumbnail for When the cold brutality of the bad ending sets in 0:28
When the cold brutality of the bad ending sets in
bestofupgoat
107 views
Thumbnail for How To Fight Deplatforming: Decentralize9:58
How To Fight Deplatforming: Decentralize
ReasonVids
1072 views
Thumbnail for Don't Expect Unions To Make a Comeback4:26
Don't Expect Unions To Make a Comeback
ReasonVids
942 views
Thumbnail for Freshest Smelling Nigga0:18
Freshest Smelling Nigga
voatcatbox
519 views
Thumbnail for Frieza Got PTSD From Goten & Trunks | ariki Anime0:53
Frieza Got PTSD From Goten & Trunks | ariki Anime
invidious
206 views
Thumbnail for Briella - Mi momento va a llegar (Video Oficial) | Briella3:10
Briella - Mi momento va a llegar (Video Oficial) | Briella
invidious
160 views
Thumbnail for I found the perfect model… | Justin Veenema1:21
I found the perfect model… | Justin Veenema
invidious
134 views
Thumbnail for @BigGuyFromQueens USES East River bait.2:46
@BigGuyFromQueens USES East River bait.
bestofupgoat
215 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
paul ryan
,
joe biden
,
tax reform
,
tax code
,
reagan
,
jobs
,
mitch mcconnell
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle