HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Should the Government Get to Define ‘Native-American’ Art? One Woman’s Free Speech Fight.

Views:794
@ReasonVids

Peggy Fontenot is a successful Native American artist who can't call her work "Native made" or "Indian made" in Oklahoma because of a recently passed law.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/reasontv
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magazine/
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason
Subscribe to our podcast at iTunes: https://goo.gl/az3a7a

Reason is the leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.

----------------

Peggy Fontenot has had a successful career as a Native American artist working in beading, silver jewelry and black-and-white photography. She's won numerous awards at art shows and has shown her work at top-tier museums.

Today her career is in jeopardy because of a 2016 state law that says only members of federally-recognized tribes can market their work as "Native American" or "Indian made." Fontenot is a part of the Patawomeck tribe, which is recognized only in the state of Virginia.

Now she's suing the state on the grounds that the law violates her First Amendment rights. "To call every state-recognized tribe fake and illegitimate is just broad sweeping and wrong," Fontenot told Reason.

Anastasia Boden of the non-profit Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing Fontenot, says the law is intended to restrict competition. She notes that State Rep. Chuck Hoskin (D), who sponsored the bill, has also served as the chief of staff for the federally-recongized Cherokee Nation. The group "certainly would have an interest in putting a law on the books that says that only federally recognized tribes can call themselves Native American," Boden says. (Rep. Hoskin declined our interview request.)

Rebecca Tushnet, a Harvard law professor, says the Oklahoma law may have been poorly crafted, but was well-intentioned. She says fraud in the Native American art market is big problem.

Oklahoma isn't enforcing the law as the case is being deliberated, allowing Fontenot to continue marketing her work as she always has. A decision is expected by the end of the year.

Produced by Paul Detrick. Shot by Detrick, Alex Manning, Mark McDaniel and Meredith Bragg.

native american
,
indian american
,
kathy ireland
,
peggy fontenot
,
chuck hoskin
,
oklahoma
,
free speech
Thumbnail for Legalize Medically-Assisted Sex: Keep Government Out of Bedrooms and Wheelchairs5:39
Legalize Medically-Assisted Sex: Keep Government Out of Bedrooms and Wheelchairs
ReasonVids
978 views
Thumbnail for How One Simple Idea Rescued the Marble Machine | Wintergatan20:44
How One Simple Idea Rescued the Marble Machine | Wintergatan
Invidious2
25 views
Thumbnail for School Choice and the Middle Class: Q&A with Matthew Ladner of the Goldwater Institute1:34
School Choice and the Middle Class: Q&A with Matthew Ladner of the Goldwater Institute
ReasonVids
877 views
Thumbnail for Was ich von efuels halte - und was mich von Volker Wissing unterscheidet. Ein Gedankengang.7:37
Was ich von efuels halte - und was mich von Volker Wissing unterscheidet. Ein Gedankengang.
poasttv.topic
638 views
Thumbnail for Clearing traffic jam0:18
Clearing traffic jam
bestofupgoat
492 views
Thumbnail for Never Forget - ((( Multiculturalists ))) intentionally pushed, and paid for the flood of 3rd world illegal trash into Western White Nations, knowing it would destroy them.1:00
Never Forget - ((( Multiculturalists ))) intentionally pushed, and paid for the flood of 3rd world illegal trash into Western White Nations, knowing it would destroy them.
bestofupgoat
298 views
Thumbnail for Philip Payton Jr.: The Crusading Capitalist Who Outwitted New York's Racist Landlords5:20
Philip Payton Jr.: The Crusading Capitalist Who Outwitted New York's Racist Landlords
ReasonVids
1065 views
Thumbnail for The Feds vs. Craig Zucker: Q&A with the Creator of Buckyballs7:33
The Feds vs. Craig Zucker: Q&A with the Creator of Buckyballs
ReasonVids
1030 views
Thumbnail for reddit Trendies Clamor for Internet Censorship - #PropagandaWatch25:20
reddit Trendies Clamor for Internet Censorship - #PropagandaWatch
corbettreport_uo
2744 views
Thumbnail for SomePkmn-LovingDude1:50
SomePkmn-LovingDude
mattknezz888
23 views
Thumbnail for Tell Us Your Story3:10
Tell Us Your Story
AmericanRenaissance
1484 views
Thumbnail for The Questionable Engineering of the 737 Max | Real Engineering13:22
The Questionable Engineering of the 737 Max | Real Engineering
invidious
342 views
Thumbnail for Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck3:28
Border Patrol Said 5 Bullets Were “Munitions of War” and Seized this American’s Truck
IJvids
975 views
Thumbnail for The communists have been at this for a long time.1:34
The communists have been at this for a long time.
bestofsaidit
725 views
Thumbnail for A Goat when he figures out the holes in his yard are not gophers but from the jews in the synagogue next door.0:33
A Goat when he figures out the holes in his yard are not gophers but from the jews in the synagogue next door.
bestofupgoat
218 views
Thumbnail for Seattle Police Chief Norm Stamper on Ending the Drug War9:52
Seattle Police Chief Norm Stamper on Ending the Drug War
ReasonVids
1122 views
Thumbnail for Stossel: Rand Paul on The Case Against Socialism5:30
Stossel: Rand Paul on The Case Against Socialism
ReasonVids
1035 views
Thumbnail for Biden Won’t End the Warfare-Surveillance State1:10:21
Biden Won’t End the Warfare-Surveillance State
ReasonVids
934 views
Thumbnail for Where's Sock Puppet's Bailout?2:26
Where's Sock Puppet's Bailout?
ReasonVids
961 views
Thumbnail for Cops at Uvalde School shooting went in and took their kids out, then went back outside to keep other parents from going in and doing anything to stop the shooter0:27
Cops at Uvalde School shooting went in and took their kids out, then went back outside to keep other parents from going in and doing anything to stop the shooter
bestofvoatxyz
941 views
Thumbnail for when White guys do roofing0:45
when White guys do roofing
bestofupgoat
86 views
Thumbnail for Porkers of the Month for December 2010: Sens. Lisa Murkowski and James Inhofe!0:56
Porkers of the Month for December 2010: Sens. Lisa Murkowski and James Inhofe!
ReasonVids
982 views
Thumbnail for How to Deal with Cops: Q&A with Steve Silverman of Flex Your Rights9:07
How to Deal with Cops: Q&A with Steve Silverman of Flex Your Rights
ReasonVids
915 views
Thumbnail for Racist robot dog 0:17
Racist robot dog
AmericanMuskrat
606 views
Thumbnail for Netinyajew admits it 0:32
Netinyajew admits it
bestofupgoat
240 views

points

Permalink
Reply
native american
,
indian american
,
kathy ireland
,
peggy fontenot
,
chuck hoskin
,
oklahoma
,
free speech
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle