HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

The 3 Rules of Hate Speech: Free Speech Rules (Episode 2)

Views:1061
@ReasonVids

Here are three rules you should know about "Hate Speech" and the First Amendment:

  1. The First Amendment protects all ideas, loving, hateful, or in between.

In the United States, “hate speech” is just a political label, like “un-American speech” or “rude speech.” Some people use the phrase broadly, some more narrowly - but there’s no legal definition, because there is no “hate speech” exception to the First Amendment..

As the Supreme Court held in 1974, “Under the First Amendment there is no such thing as a false idea. However pernicious an opinion may seem, we depend for its correction not on the conscience of judges and juries but on the competition of other ideas."

Or, in 2017:
“...the proudest boast of our free speech jurisprudence is that we protect the freedom to express ‘the thought that we hate.'"

That’s from Matal v. Tam, in which the government denied a trademark to an Asian-American band, because the band’s name was seen by some as a racial slur. The government wasn’t even trying to ban the name; it was just denying trademark registration to people who used the name.

But even that, the Court concluded, was unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination, and violated the First Amendment.

  1. Some speech is not protected by the First Amendment, regardless of whether it’s bigoted or hateful

Threats of violence are constitutionally unprotected. That includes all threats--racist threats, threats to police officers, business owners, the President, anyone.

Likewise, intentionally inciting immediate violence is sometimes punishable. Classic example: Giving a speech to a mob outside a building, urging them to burn it down.

Personal insults said to someone’s face might also be punishable, as so-called “fighting words.” That’s true regardless of whether the insults stem from personal hostility or group hatred related to race, religion, and the like.

Indeed, in 1992, the Supreme Court struck down an ordinance that specially targeted bigoted fighting words.

  1. Hate crime laws are constitutional, so long as when they punish violence or vandalism, not speech

The classic example is Wisconsin v. Mitchell, the 1993 case in which the Supreme Court unanimously upheld hate crimes laws. Todd Mitchell, a young black man, urged some friends to beat up a white boy because the boy was white.

Wisconsin law made the beating into a more serious crime because the boy was targeted based on his race. The Court said this is fine, because “a physical assault is not by any stretch of the imagination expressive conduct protected by the First Amendment.”

And while the law increased the punishment because of the defendant’s intent, the law often punishes people more because of why they did what they did.

Killing someone for money will get you a harsher punishment than killing them out of momentary anger. Likewise, firing an employee because of his race will get you a civil lawsuit; firing an employee for most other reasons won’t.

None of this covers the mere expression of hateful ideas, or the use of words that some see as hateful. Those are generally protected by the First Amendment.

But why? The Justices generally agree that racist ideas, for instances, are wrong and dangerous. Why would the Justices say hate speech is constitutionally protected?

Because they don’t trust government officials to decide which ideas are wrong and dangerous.

They worry that if government officials had the power to ban evil ideas, that power would quickly stretch to punishing a wide range of debate and dissent. And they see the First Amendment as requiring that distrust.

In the words of Justice Black, echoed by the Supreme Court in 1972, “The freedoms ...guaranteed by the First Amendment must be accorded to the ideas we hate or sooner or later they will be denied to the ideas we cherish.”

Written by Eugene Volokh, a First Amendment law professor at UCLA.
Produced and edited by Austin Bragg, who is not.

This is the second episode of Free Speech Rules, a video series on free speech and the law. Volokh is the co-founder of the Volokh Conspiracy, which is hosted at Reason.com.

This is not legal advice.
If this were legal advice, it would be followed by a bill.
Please use responsibly.

Music: "Lobby Time" by Kevin MacLeod, Incompetech.com
Music: "You Make Me Alive" by The Slants
Wookie Icon by Jory Raphael, symbolicons.com

For full text visit https://reason.com/reasontv/2019/02/19/the-3-rules-of-hate-speech

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
hate speech
,
free speech
,
fighting words
    Thumbnail for Legal Weed Did More to Stop Drug Smuggling Than Any Wall10:17
    Legal Weed Did More to Stop Drug Smuggling Than Any Wall
    ReasonVids
    958 views
    Thumbnail for Something About Street Fighter II (Loud Sound Warning) 🚗🤜😵💫 | TerminalMontage5:59
    Something About Street Fighter II (Loud Sound Warning) 🚗🤜😵💫 | TerminalMontage
    invidious
    451 views
    Thumbnail for Steve Horwitz on Austrian Economics, Bleeding Heart Libertarians, and Family9:24
    Steve Horwitz on Austrian Economics, Bleeding Heart Libertarians, and Family
    ReasonVids
    947 views
    Thumbnail for School Choice and the Middle Class: Q&A with Matthew Ladner of the Goldwater Institute1:34
    School Choice and the Middle Class: Q&A with Matthew Ladner of the Goldwater Institute
    ReasonVids
    861 views
    Thumbnail for You Need to Game Jam More Often | BMo8:19
    You Need to Game Jam More Often | BMo
    tech.topic
    681 views
    Thumbnail for The Pot - TOOL - Live cover6:32
    The Pot - TOOL - Live cover
    invidious
    374 views
    Thumbnail for LEVIATHAN BOSS in DEAD SPACE REMAKE PS5 Walkthrough Gameplay Part 10 (FULL GAME) | theRadBrad36:03
    LEVIATHAN BOSS in DEAD SPACE REMAKE PS5 Walkthrough Gameplay Part 10 (FULL GAME) | theRadBrad
    invidious
    353 views
    Thumbnail for The FBI Basically Admits they Orchestrated January 6th for Political Gain and to Use Against Trump.11:04
    The FBI Basically Admits they Orchestrated January 6th for Political Gain and to Use Against Trump.
    bestofsaidit
    1585 views
    Thumbnail for Gov. Gary Johnson Among the Occupy Wall Street Protesters5:21
    Gov. Gary Johnson Among the Occupy Wall Street Protesters
    ReasonVids
    836 views
    Thumbnail for Can You Fight Radical Islam with Western Bestsellers?21:37
    Can You Fight Radical Islam with Western Bestsellers?
    ReasonVids
    857 views
    Thumbnail for Asteron OF0:36
    Asteron OF
    Anteros
    181 views
    Thumbnail for Chimp Thought She Had Lost Baby During Child Birth, Vets Revived It0:21
    Chimp Thought She Had Lost Baby During Child Birth, Vets Revived It
    bestofvoatxyz
    487 views
    Thumbnail for If You’re Happy And You Know It | Kids Songs | Super Simple Songs1:38
    If You’re Happy And You Know It | Kids Songs | Super Simple Songs
    kids.topic
    98 views
    Thumbnail for In 2020, IBM put implants into US prisoners w/o their knowledge suppressing moods & 24/7 bio-spying4:09
    In 2020, IBM put implants into US prisoners w/o their knowledge suppressing moods & 24/7 bio-spying
    bestofupgoat
    134 views
    Thumbnail for When the snake hits the fan0:20
    When the snake hits the fan
    AOUisgay
    518 views
    Thumbnail for just a nanny dog tucking the boys in0:26
    just a nanny dog tucking the boys in
    bestofupgoat
    414 views
    Thumbnail for DECADES Of Pants-Wetting Lies About Iran! | The Jimmy Dore Show4:57
    DECADES Of Pants-Wetting Lies About Iran! | The Jimmy Dore Show
    invidious
    219 views
    Thumbnail for FUTBOL Y TRANSAS EN VIVO 🔥 | AZZ2:54:35
    FUTBOL Y TRANSAS EN VIVO 🔥 | AZZ
    invidious
    62 views
    Thumbnail for False Flags, Gun Grabs | Grunt Speak Shorts11:06
    False Flags, Gun Grabs | Grunt Speak Shorts
    Terrence Popp
    1538 views
    Thumbnail for Stone Age Minds: A conversation with evolutionary psychologists Leda Cosmides and John Tooby9:59
    Stone Age Minds: A conversation with evolutionary psychologists Leda Cosmides and John Tooby
    ReasonVids
    919 views
    Thumbnail for Brutal crab0:09
    Brutal crab
    bestofvoatxyz
    349 views
    Thumbnail for Cat fight in aisle 50:34
    Cat fight in aisle 5
    bestofvoatxyz
    773 views
    Thumbnail for 2025中美國力拐點!韓國波音737客機墜毀! 亞塞拜然墜機 普丁致歉|【國際直球對決】20241229完整版@全球大視野Global_Vision | 全球大視野2:01:16
    2025中美國力拐點!韓國波音737客機墜毀! 亞塞拜然墜機 普丁致歉|【國際直球對決】20241229完整版@全球大視野Global_Vision | 全球大視野
    invidious
    108 views
    Thumbnail for Advocate for a White USA on Shared Values with Israel3:15
    Advocate for a White USA on Shared Values with Israel
    AmericanRenaissance
    1326 views
    Thumbnail for Dear ladies--what's preventing you from looking like this?0:18
    Dear ladies--what's preventing you from looking like this?
    AOU
    1155 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
hate speech
,
free speech
,
fighting words
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle