HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Cops with Drones: Alameda Co., CA Weighs Technology vs. Privacy

Views:907
@ReasonVids

For a long time, drones - unmanned aircraft - were used only by the military. Now local law enforcement wants them for police work such as surveillance and search-and-rescue missions. That in turn has sparked a fierce debate over the balance between cutting-edge law enforcement technology and the privacy rights of citizens.

In February, Reason TV covered an Alameda County, California public protection committee meeting in which Sheriff Gregory Ahern announced that he planned on using a laptop-sized drone (he prefers to call it an "unmanned aerial system") for search and rescue. "It's mission specific to search areas for lost children or elderly or Alzheimer's patients to search an area that it would be very difficult for our personnel to get to," said Sheriff Ahern.

Residents and civil liberties advocates are skeptical that drone use would remain so narrowly defined for very long. At the meeting, Linda Lye of the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California took issue with the sheriff's submitted draft of a privacy policy. She it's not specific enough about what the sheriff can and cannot do with drones.

"If the sheriff wants a drone for search and rescue then the policy should say he can only use it for search and rescue," said Lye. "Unfortunately under his policy he can deploy a drone for search and rescue, but then use the data for untold other purposes. That is a huge loophole, it's an exception that swallows the rule."

Lye urged the public protection committee not to approve the drone until stricter safeguards were in place. She pointed out that the safeguards were important because the technology will develop very quickly - and possibly to a point where citizens don't have control of their Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable searches and seizures. Indeed, Alameda County could serve as the baseline for police and sheriff's departments across the country, so getting it right there may affect all Americans.

The sheriff plans on applying for permission from the Federal Aviation Administration to fly aircraft above 400 feet and plans to pay for the drone with a federal grant. MuckRock.com made a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request for the grant made to the Department of Homeland Security in July 2012. The request revealed that Sheriff Ahern was looking to purchase a drone equipped with a something called a "Forward Looking Infrared camera." These thermal-imaging devices detect radiation given off by heat from people or animals, opening up a wide variety of concerns.

Criminal law experts such as Laurie Levenson of Loyola Law School say law enforcement hasn't been given enough legal guidance on drones yet.

"If you say we're going to use it for a manhunt, what do you call a manhunt? If you say you want to use it to find missing persons, well, how far can you go with that?" says Levenson. She says that it's a matter of drawing lines because it's just too easy to become Big Brother without them. What happens, for instance, if police capture evidence of unrelated criminal activity while searching for a lost toddler? Can they use that to trigger arrests and prosecution?

Trevor Timm of the Electronic Frontier Foundation points out that it is very hard to draw lines with police because, once police have a certain power, they never want to give it up.

"Police always seem to want to push the boundaries as far as the law will take them and sometimes over those boundaries," says Timm.

He points to law enforcement and cell phone data as an example. The New York Times reported in 2012 that law enforcement made 1.3 million demands in 2011 of phone companies for subscriber locations, text messages, and other information. Because there weren't strict privacy rules in place when mobile phones first exploded onto the market, it made it that much easier for law enforcement to obtain civilian data without search warrants or users' approval or even knowing about the requests.

"Generally there is this real friction between technology and civil liberties and we haven't really figured out how to deal with it," says Levenson. We don't know how to deal with it because technology is developing a lot faster than the law can keep up. Government cameras are everywhere these days and the laws that deal with them go back to the time of the framers of the Constitution. "What did they know about drones?" asks Levenson.

About 8 minutes.

Written and produced by Paul Detrick. Camera by Alex Manning, Zach Weissmueller, Tracy Oppenheimer, and Detrick.

Go to http://www.reason.com for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube Channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.

For Reason's coverage of drones, check out:

http://reason.com/tags/drones

paul detrick
,
american civil liberties union
,
spy
,
california
,
cops
,
libertarian
,
police
,
crime
,
aclu
,
drones
,
court
,
attorney
,
lawyer (profession)
,
security
,
judge
,
criminal
,
surveillance
,
fbi
,
terrorism
,
terror
,
bombings
,
\fusion centers\
,
f.b.i. (instrumental)
    Thumbnail for Sequester Shocker: It Feels Like Nothing's Changed1:42
    Sequester Shocker: It Feels Like Nothing's Changed
    ReasonVids
    980 views
    Thumbnail for 6uild 6ack 6etter1:30
    6uild 6ack 6etter
    bestofupgoat
    271 views
    Thumbnail for 5 Reasons Obamacare Won't Save You2:26
    5 Reasons Obamacare Won't Save You
    ReasonVids
    982 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Blackwater and Erik Prince Do Mostly GOOD7:29
    Stossel: Blackwater and Erik Prince Do Mostly GOOD
    ReasonVids
    902 views
    Thumbnail for Anal Probes Run Amok: Drug-Sniffing Dogs Must Be Stopped.4:18
    Anal Probes Run Amok: Drug-Sniffing Dogs Must Be Stopped.
    ReasonVids
    914 views
    Thumbnail for It's popping off in the Netherlands, as farmers show up to spray politicians' houses with manure0:36
    It's popping off in the Netherlands, as farmers show up to spray politicians' houses with manure
    nikamats
    878 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Supreme Court Ruling May Crush Unions4:36
    Stossel: Supreme Court Ruling May Crush Unions
    ReasonVids
    938 views
    Thumbnail for 'March Against Monsanto' Anti-GMO Protest in Los Angeles5:03
    'March Against Monsanto' Anti-GMO Protest in Los Angeles
    ReasonVids
    870 views
    Thumbnail for Hillary and Bernie Supporters in Their Own Words Before the NH Debate2:48
    Hillary and Bernie Supporters in Their Own Words Before the NH Debate
    ReasonVids
    879 views
    Thumbnail for It's Different For The Media0:14
    It's Different For The Media
    bestofupgoat
    375 views
    Thumbnail for UPS vs. FEDEX: Ultimate Whiteboard Remix1:48
    UPS vs. FEDEX: Ultimate Whiteboard Remix
    ReasonVids
    925 views
    Thumbnail for Too Big To Regulate: Barron's Gene Epstein on Dodd-Frank25:35
    Too Big To Regulate: Barron's Gene Epstein on Dodd-Frank
    ReasonVids
    882 views
    Thumbnail for Sheniqua absolutely SEETHING she has no white man to go home to 1:30
    Sheniqua absolutely SEETHING she has no white man to go home to
    bestofupgoat
    426 views
    Thumbnail for Don't Fear the Refugees9:19
    Don't Fear the Refugees
    ReasonVids
    1049 views
    Thumbnail for Gov’t Wants to Bulldoze Retiree’s 50-year Family Home1:51
    Gov’t Wants to Bulldoze Retiree’s 50-year Family Home
    IJvids
    895 views
    Thumbnail for ‘Unconditional War’ on Racism11:08
    ‘Unconditional War’ on Racism
    AmericanRenaissance
    856 views
    Thumbnail for NYC Apartment residents say they are being terrorized, beaten by "teens"2:08
    NYC Apartment residents say they are being terrorized, beaten by "teens"
    bestofvoatxyz
    879 views
    Thumbnail for Good boy!0:12
    Good boy!
    bestofvoatxyz
    371 views
    Thumbnail for Life After Liberation: Triumph and Tragedy in South Africa10:02
    Life After Liberation: Triumph and Tragedy in South Africa
    ReasonVids
    955 views
    Thumbnail for Policing is Too Important to be Left to the Government: Economist Ed Stringham5:29
    Policing is Too Important to be Left to the Government: Economist Ed Stringham
    ReasonVids
    865 views
    Thumbnail for When Democrats Loved Deregulation4:54
    When Democrats Loved Deregulation
    ReasonVids
    918 views
    Thumbnail for Tell Us Your Story3:10
    Tell Us Your Story
    AmericanRenaissance
    1445 views

points

Permalink
Reply
paul detrick
,
american civil liberties union
,
spy
,
california
,
cops
,
libertarian
,
police
,
crime
,
aclu
,
drones
,
court
,
attorney
,
lawyer (profession)
,
security
,
judge
,
criminal
,
surveillance
,
fbi
,
terrorism
,
terror
,
bombings
,
\fusion centers\
,
f.b.i. (instrumental)
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle