HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

3 Reasons the US MILITARY Should NOT Fight Ebola

Views:998
@ReasonVids

President Obama is sending thousands of U.S. troops to West Africa to fight the deadly Ebola virus. Their mission will be to construct treatment centers and provide medical training to health-care workers in the local communities.

But is it really a good idea to send soldiers to provide this sort of aid?

Here are 3 reasons why militarizing humanitarian aid is a very bad idea:

  1. Militarized Aid Erodes Humanitarian Principles

Humanitarian aid must be perceived as neutral and not driven by political or military objectives. Using the military in a humanitarian crisis works against that and potentially instigates further unrest.

Attacks against humanitarian personnel have been rising in the past decade precisely because of a perceived blurring of humanitarian, political, and military goals.

And our track record in Africa warrants such skepticism. In the past six years, the U.S. military has expanded its troop presense in Africa via humanitarian missions specifically designed to establish points of entry for future military missions.

Local communities face a hell of a bind: if they don't accept help from the military, they run the risk of missing out on much needed humanitarian aid. That erodes the trust needed to establish a working relationship between aid workers and local communities.

  1. Militarized Aid is Ineffective in the Long Term

Militarized aid is often backed by huge budgets that are supposed to be spent quickly.

Indeed, the Department of Defense has already allocated $1 billion to fight Ebola.

The pressure to spend massive amounts is often coupled with pressure to achieve short-term political goals.

That in turn translates into an ineffective use of funds. Accountability and follow-up are in short supply, too, meaning the same mistakes get repeated over and over.

  1. Militarized Aid Diminishes the Supply of Civil Aid

Many politicians who support militarized aid claim that the military is the only institution capable of handling the humanitarian crisis at hand.

If this is true—and too often it is—this highlights the neglect of civilian-led programs that are more likely to get the job done.

By constantly relying on the military for humanitarian efforts, we're stifling efforts to grow civilian-led organizations that can handle the complicated logistics necessary to address large-scale humanitarian crises.

About 2 minutes.

Produced by Amanda Winkler and co-written with Nick Gillespie, who narrates. Camera by Jim Epstein with Anthony L. Fisher.

Go to http://reason.com/reasontv/2014/10/14/3-reasons-the-us-military-should-not-fig for downloadable versions, full text, and links to all claims made above.

Subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel and get automatic notifications when new material goes live.

ebola (disease or medical condition)
,
ebola virus (disease cause)
,
united states army (armed force)
,
reason (magazine)
,
amanda c. winkler
,
nick gillespie (author)
,
reason foundation
,
west africa (location)
,
foreign aid
,
united states armed forces (armed force)
,
humanitarian aid (literature subject)
,
united nations (membership organization)
,
liberia (country)
,
infection (disease or medical condition)
    Thumbnail for Strawberry Cough: Biography of an Award-Winning Cannabis Strain6:29
    Strawberry Cough: Biography of an Award-Winning Cannabis Strain
    ReasonVids
    887 views
    Thumbnail for Half-baked: Gov't Restricts Homemade Cookie Sales1:54
    Half-baked: Gov't Restricts Homemade Cookie Sales
    IJvids
    939 views
    Thumbnail for PayPal Stock TANKS After INSANE Social Credit System BACKFIRED, PayPal Claims It Was An Error21:49
    PayPal Stock TANKS After INSANE Social Credit System BACKFIRED, PayPal Claims It Was An Error
    bestofsaidit
    944 views
    Thumbnail for All For Love5:41
    All For Love
    murdochmurdoch
    1182 views
    Thumbnail for Adrian Moore, Len Gilroy, Tim Cavanaugh & Anthony Randazzo: On Privatization & Government Reform57:08
    Adrian Moore, Len Gilroy, Tim Cavanaugh & Anthony Randazzo: On Privatization & Government Reform
    ReasonVids
    937 views
    Thumbnail for LAPD Had "No Idea" Who They Were Shooting At In Dorner Pursuit, Says Victims' Attorney5:49
    LAPD Had "No Idea" Who They Were Shooting At In Dorner Pursuit, Says Victims' Attorney
    ReasonVids
    934 views
    Thumbnail for Richard Viguerie on the Future of Conservatism7:34
    Richard Viguerie on the Future of Conservatism
    ReasonVids
    820 views
    Thumbnail for Are We In the Final Days of Marijuana Prohibition?3:16
    Are We In the Final Days of Marijuana Prohibition?
    ReasonVids
    882 views
    Thumbnail for EPA Rulemaking Matters! Subtitled For Your Protection1:38
    EPA Rulemaking Matters! Subtitled For Your Protection
    ReasonVids
    827 views
    Thumbnail for Police Peddle "Stolen" iPhones, Arrest Buyers: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!1:58
    Police Peddle "Stolen" iPhones, Arrest Buyers: Don't Cops Have Better Things to Do?!
    ReasonVids
    903 views
    Thumbnail for The Prosecution of Julian Assange Is an Assault on the First Amendment14:06
    The Prosecution of Julian Assange Is an Assault on the First Amendment
    ReasonVids
    1040 views
    Thumbnail for The End of Play: Why Kids Need Unstructured Time30:34
    The End of Play: Why Kids Need Unstructured Time
    ReasonVids
    910 views
    Thumbnail for @Sal_180 has a rude awakening0:43
    @Sal_180 has a rude awakening
    bestofupgoat
    94 views
    Thumbnail for Unbelievable! Massive Freedom Rally In Australia! Patriot Uprising!!!2:06
    Unbelievable! Massive Freedom Rally In Australia! Patriot Uprising!!!
    AOU
    1953 views
    Thumbnail for The Man Who Brought Obamacare Back to the Supreme Court: CEI's Lawson Bader on King v. Burwell5:34
    The Man Who Brought Obamacare Back to the Supreme Court: CEI's Lawson Bader on King v. Burwell
    ReasonVids
    840 views
    Thumbnail for Can the Free Market End Global Poverty? Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz vs. NYU's William Easterly1:27:28
    Can the Free Market End Global Poverty? Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz vs. NYU's William Easterly
    ReasonVids
    763 views
    Thumbnail for We’re Supposed to Fight… Robots now? | Sensei Seth Reacts10:52
    We’re Supposed to Fight… Robots now? | Sensei Seth Reacts
    invidious
    358 views
    Thumbnail for How Biden's Agenda Is Causing Inflation6:40
    How Biden's Agenda Is Causing Inflation
    ReasonVids
    1007 views
    Thumbnail for So you've heard of caber tossing.0:02
    So you've heard of caber tossing.
    voatcatbox
    475 views
    Thumbnail for Former NYPD Chief Bernard Kerik Discusses Ferguson, Police Militarization, and Clemency25:43
    Former NYPD Chief Bernard Kerik Discusses Ferguson, Police Militarization, and Clemency
    ReasonVids
    917 views
    Thumbnail for Dumb cat puns0:35
    Dumb cat puns
    AOUisgay
    578 views
    Thumbnail for What did we learn today?3:32
    What did we learn today?
    ReasonVids
    885 views
    Thumbnail for Sneaky jews0:18
    Sneaky jews
    bestofupgoat
    547 views
    Thumbnail for [🔴특보] 지리산 뚫리면 3시간 내 천왕봉으로…'막아야 한다' 인력·헬기 총동원|산불 '재확산' 조짐에 미군 헬기 투입 등 '총력' / 연합뉴스TV (YonhapnewsTV) | 연합뉴스TV11:55:01
    [🔴특보] 지리산 뚫리면 3시간 내 천왕봉으로…'막아야 한다' 인력·헬기 총동원|산불 '재확산' 조짐에 미군 헬기 투입 등 '총력' / 연합뉴스TV (YonhapnewsTV) | 연합뉴스TV
    invidious
    68 views
    Thumbnail for What Should Have Happened at the Amy Coney Barrett Hearings5:31
    What Should Have Happened at the Amy Coney Barrett Hearings
    ReasonVids
    886 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ebola (disease or medical condition)
,
ebola virus (disease cause)
,
united states army (armed force)
,
reason (magazine)
,
amanda c. winkler
,
nick gillespie (author)
,
reason foundation
,
west africa (location)
,
foreign aid
,
united states armed forces (armed force)
,
humanitarian aid (literature subject)
,
united nations (membership organization)
,
liberia (country)
,
infection (disease or medical condition)
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle