HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Facebook’s Oversight Board Was Right to Ban Trump

Views:991
@ReasonVids

It's a working model for non-state governance in cyberspace that is vastly preferable to government control of social media.

------------------
Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/ReasonTV
Like us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Reason.Magaz...
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/reason

Reason is the planet's leading source of news, politics, and culture from a libertarian perspective. Go to reason.com for a point of view you won't get from legacy media and old left-right opinion magazines.
----------------

When Facebook's independent Oversight Board recently upheld the social media platform's ban on former President Donald Trump, the decision drew mostly negative reviews, with press outlets calling it "little more than judicial theater" or a "distraction" from more serious issues raised by Big Tech.

The Oversight Board comprises 20 individuals with backgrounds in tech, law, politics, and free speech activism. It's funded by an irrevocable trust set up by Facebook and has a legally binding final say over suspensions.

Its critics are wrong in at least two major ways.

First, the board made the right call in this case. It agreed that by its own rules, Facebook was justified in shutting down Trump after he twice posted praise of violent rioters even as they raised hell in the Capitol. It also correctly found that Facebook violated its terms of service by suspending Trump indefinitely. The board has given Mark Zuckerberg and company up to six months to render a final decision on the former president.

Second, and more importantly, the board is a serious model for non-state governance in cyberspace. It's far from perfect, but it's preferable to rules being forced on the service by politicians. Only up and running since the start of this year, the board has already been twice as likely to overturn Facebook's decisions as it is to uphold them, a strong show of accountability and seriousness of purpose.

In one case, the board restored images of naked breasts in a post about cancer that had been removed by an automated system. The board chastised the platform for making the decision without "proper human oversight." In another, Facebook had removed a post that inaccurately quoted Nazi propaganda minister Joseph Goebbels and implicitly compared him to Trump. Because Goebbels is on a list of prohibited people, the site took down the post even though it was intended as critical of both the Nazi and Trump. "Any rules which restrict freedom of expression must be clear, precise and publicly accessible," reads the decision, which also faulted Facebook for failing to inform the user why his post was originally taken down.

"I think there is actually a bit of a libertarian paradox here," John Samples, a vice president at the Cato Institute and a member of the Oversight Board, tells Reason in an interview. On the one hand, he says, there's an interest in no content moderation and leaving all decisions of what's on Facebook (or any other site) to end users who can control what they engage via filters and other tools. On the other hand, social media platforms are corporations that are trying to maximize shareholder value and the number of users by creating particular types of environments. He says that a private company moderating content on its platform is fully in keeping with libertarian principles. 

Calls to take away the rights of platforms to police their own sites are growing across the political spectrum. Republicans in Florida are trying to restrict social media platforms from banning users while Democrats in Colorado are pushing bans on hate speech. Progressives like Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D–Mass.) and conservatives like Sen. Josh Hawley (R–Mo.) talk about treating social media platforms as common carriers, akin to telephone companies, that would be tightly regulated by the government.


Produced by Noor Greene; written and narrated by Nick Gillespie; audio by Ian Keyser; additional graphics by Paul Detrick.

Photos: Photo 43805645 © Dolphfyn | Dreamstime.com, ID 124963884 © Mohamed Ahmed Soliman | Dreamstime.com, ID 29659925© Photographer London| Dreamstime.com, ID 179599250 © Frédéric Legrand | Dreamstime.com, Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call/Newscom, Joel Marklund/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom, Lev Radin/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom, Jeremy Hogan/Polaris/Newscom, Toby Melville /REUTERS/Newscom, Richard B. Levine/Newscom, Lev Radin/Pacific Press/Newscom, Douliery Olivier/ABACA/Newscom, Abaca Press/Douliery, Olivier/Abaca/Sipa USA/Newscom, Graeme Jennings - Pool Via Cnp/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom, PoolCNP/Pool via CNP/INSTARimages/Cover Images/Newscom; Niall Carson/ZUMAPRESS/Newscom

libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
facebook
,
facebookoversightboard
,
trump
    Thumbnail for Mayor Francis Suarez Wants To Turn Miami Into an Un-Woke, Pro-Bitcoin, Tech Billionaire’s Paradise13:33
    Mayor Francis Suarez Wants To Turn Miami Into an Un-Woke, Pro-Bitcoin, Tech Billionaire’s Paradise
    ReasonVids
    913 views
    Thumbnail for Abortion & Libertarians: Nick Gillespie, Ronald Bailey, Mollie Hemingway & Katherine Mangu-Ward50:58
    Abortion & Libertarians: Nick Gillespie, Ronald Bailey, Mollie Hemingway & Katherine Mangu-Ward
    ReasonVids
    922 views
    Thumbnail for Interview with Waffen SS Officer Léon Degrelle 1:57:55
    Interview with Waffen SS Officer Léon Degrelle
    NachtWaffen
    652 views
    Thumbnail for School Principal Bans Homemade Lunches! Nanny of the Month (April 2011)1:47
    School Principal Bans Homemade Lunches! Nanny of the Month (April 2011)
    ReasonVids
    813 views
    Thumbnail for GPT4ALL: Install 'ChatGPT' Locally (weights & fine-tuning!) - Tutorial | Matthew Berman8:05
    GPT4ALL: Install 'ChatGPT' Locally (weights & fine-tuning!) - Tutorial | Matthew Berman
    tech.topic
    577 views
    Thumbnail for Chips Ahoy Gets Woke! Virtue Signals About Diversity; FAILS MISERABLY!8:58
    Chips Ahoy Gets Woke! Virtue Signals About Diversity; FAILS MISERABLY!
    AOUisgay
    465 views
    Thumbnail for Banning Soda, Lessons from Wisconsin, & Obama the Pot Smoker7:37
    Banning Soda, Lessons from Wisconsin, & Obama the Pot Smoker
    ReasonVids
    954 views
    Thumbnail for This Used to be My Alarm Clock0:19
    This Used to be My Alarm Clock
    bestofvoatxyz
    748 views
    Thumbnail for Portly ching chong knows how to sell corndogs 1:00
    Portly ching chong knows how to sell corndogs
    bestofupgoat
    73 views
    Thumbnail for Every Day is Women's Day | Grunt Speak Live1:32:58
    Every Day is Women's Day | Grunt Speak Live
    Terrence Popp
    1307 views
    Thumbnail for Whitney Webb "These people are about to UNDERMINE RFK, Jr. and the MAHA movement" Does Trump know? | Redacted43:34
    Whitney Webb "These people are about to UNDERMINE RFK, Jr. and the MAHA movement" Does Trump know? | Redacted
    invidious
    100 views
    Thumbnail for BREAKING! Alex Jones Responds To $4.2 Million Sandy Hook Verdict7:44
    BREAKING! Alex Jones Responds To $4.2 Million Sandy Hook Verdict
    bestofwolfballs
    829 views
    Thumbnail for Morticians Association of America Endorses President Obama's Tough New Fuel Efficiency Standards1:14
    Morticians Association of America Endorses President Obama's Tough New Fuel Efficiency Standards
    ReasonVids
    973 views
    Thumbnail for Billionaires vs. Brooklyn's Best Bar: Eminent Domain Abuse & The Atlantic Yards Project4:48
    Billionaires vs. Brooklyn's Best Bar: Eminent Domain Abuse & The Atlantic Yards Project
    ReasonVids
    867 views
    Thumbnail for We Got on Grindr at CPAC2:48
    We Got on Grindr at CPAC
    ReasonVids
    912 views
    Thumbnail for Deer scores a goal0:12
    Deer scores a goal
    bestofupgoat
    246 views
    Thumbnail for Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!1:41
    Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!
    ReasonVids
    774 views
    Thumbnail for Don’t worry that many of the ballots have the same signature and don’t appear to even have a crease in them just keep counting2:10
    Don’t worry that many of the ballots have the same signature and don’t appear to even have a crease in them just keep counting
    AOU
    2838 views
    Thumbnail for What We Saw at the Glenn Beck Rally in DC6:25
    What We Saw at the Glenn Beck Rally in DC
    ReasonVids
    998 views
    Thumbnail for Infinifat | Grunt Speak Shorts7:15
    Infinifat | Grunt Speak Shorts
    Terrence Popp
    1040 views
    Thumbnail for protesting nazi robots1:03
    protesting nazi robots
    bestofupgoat
    90 views
    Thumbnail for Found footage of @postwallhelena trying to escape the upgoat plantation AGAIN! 0:27
    Found footage of @postwallhelena trying to escape the upgoat plantation AGAIN!
    bestofupgoat
    214 views
    Thumbnail for Caption contest.0:19
    Caption contest.
    bestofupgoat
    195 views
    Thumbnail for Gary Johnson or Ron Paul?2:20
    Gary Johnson or Ron Paul?
    ReasonVids
    802 views
    Thumbnail for Scenes from the Ron Paul Rally for the Republic4:36
    Scenes from the Ron Paul Rally for the Republic
    ReasonVids
    915 views

points

Permalink
Reply
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
reason.com
,
reason.tv
,
reasontv
,
facebook
,
facebookoversightboard
,
trump
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle