HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Gov't Official with NO Police Authority Detained Drivers, Granted Qualified Immunity

Views:992
@IJvids

Do you think anyone who works for the government—not just the police—should be able to pull you over and detain you?

https://ij.org/case/minnesota-csi/

And if a government employee who was never granted police powers assumes these powers unilaterally and clearly violates your constitutional rights, should you be able to hold them to account? Or should they be allowed to get off scot-free through “qualified immunity” merely because they work for the government?

Across the nation, government officials are routinely exceeding their authority and violating the rights of ordinary Americans but are escaping accountability because of the court-created doctrine of qualified immunity. As a result, citizens have been beaten in unprovoked attacks, detained illegally, and even killed by government workers. But the victims and their families have been denied their day in court to hold these bad actors accountable because courts across the nation—following the lead of the U.S. Supreme Court—refuse to enforce constitutional limits on government officials who, they say, are shielded by qualified immunity.

When the U.S. Supreme Court created qualified immunity, it said it was balancing “two evils.” On the one hand, the Court conceded that granting qualified immunity would sometimes leave people without a remedy when government employees violated their rights. On the other hand, if suits were broadly allowed, those tasked with performing government jobs could be afraid to execute these tasks to the best of their abilities.

Qualified immunity was the Court’s attempt to get this balance right. It provided government officials with a protection from lawsuits, but only if these officials were executing the duties prescribed to them by law. In other words, immunity would be available only in suits “arising from actions within the scope of an official’s duties.”

If there is one thing that proponents and opponents of qualified immunity agreed on, this was it: A government official’s ability to claim qualified immunity could be raised only in in defense of their actions while doing their job; they couldn’t receive qualified immunity when their actions far exceed any reasonable interpretation of their authority.

But this baseline premise is no longer the case.

Several months ago, the U.S. Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals granted qualified immunity to a county engineer who acted like a modern-day “Dwight Schrute” from the TV show “The Office.” Despite having no authority whatsoever to act like a police officer, this engineer pretended to be a traffic cop by pulling over two trucks traveling peacefully on a highway and detaining the drivers for three hours. He then called a local sheriff’s office, tribal police, and state troopers, asking them all to come and ticket the drivers because they were over a weight limit that he had made up less than an hour before. When state troopers finally arrived, they ticketed one driver but dismissed the ticket the following day.

In the end, the engineer unconstitutionally detained the drivers and their trucks and forced the police to waste valuable time. But for some reason, the court granted qualified immunity to the county engineer, who has no business performing traffic stops, for his unlawful detention of the drivers.

The Eighth Circuit’s decision runs in the face of the Supreme Court’s precedent on qualified immunity. It is also inconsistent with this nation’s historical practices. To ensure that rogue agents are not able to cloak themselves in an unjustified immunity, the Institute for Justice (“IJ”) now represents the owner of the trucks (Central Specialties, Inc., “CSI”) in seeking Supreme Court review of the Eighth Circuit’s decision granting qualified immunity to the county engineer. This case is part of IJ’s Project on Immunity and Accountability, which is devoted to the simple idea that government officials are not above the rules; if citizens must follow the law, then government must follow the Constitution.
Donate to IJ: https://ij.org/support/give-now/

ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
    Thumbnail for Gov't Says "Naaayyyy" to Horse Massage1:59
    Gov't Says "Naaayyyy" to Horse Massage
    IJvids
    910 views
    Thumbnail for Pulled over with 50 kg in the trunk1:00
    Pulled over with 50 kg in the trunk
    tylerthe-theatre
    1055 views
    Thumbnail for Creating a Libertarian "Wall-E" with "Silver Circle" Director Pasha Roberts2:50
    Creating a Libertarian "Wall-E" with "Silver Circle" Director Pasha Roberts
    ReasonVids
    893 views
    Thumbnail for Why They Call Us Names8:36
    Why They Call Us Names
    AmericanRenaissance
    1431 views
    Thumbnail for What Slumdog Millionaire can teach us about economic stimulus6:25
    What Slumdog Millionaire can teach us about economic stimulus
    ReasonVids
    967 views
    Thumbnail for wife said to stop drinking beer for breakfast | FunnyMemeSpot0:08
    wife said to stop drinking beer for breakfast | FunnyMemeSpot
    invidious
    123 views
    Thumbnail for Respect original content2:31
    Respect original content
    bestofupgoat
    373 views
    Thumbnail for Most Inefficient Staircase in Minecraft | Vivilly0:43
    Most Inefficient Staircase in Minecraft | Vivilly
    invidious
    97 views
    Thumbnail for Paranoid Horse0:28
    Paranoid Horse
    bestofvoatxyz
    452 views
    Thumbnail for Future of Spaceflight: XCOR's Doug Jones Talks w Reason's Brian Doherty22:51
    Future of Spaceflight: XCOR's Doug Jones Talks w Reason's Brian Doherty
    ReasonVids
    918 views
    Thumbnail for Bill Simon: The Candidates Professor7:52
    Bill Simon: The Candidates Professor
    ReasonVids
    850 views
    Thumbnail for Why Student Activists Need Free Speech: What to learn from Mizzou and Yale1:43
    Why Student Activists Need Free Speech: What to learn from Mizzou and Yale
    ReasonVids
    969 views
    Thumbnail for The Power Hungry Podcast: Judith Curry | Robert Bryce54:06
    The Power Hungry Podcast: Judith Curry | Robert Bryce
    science.topic
    119 views
    Thumbnail for Why Didn't Darth Vader Use The Force To Heal His Wounds? | Star Wars Insider0:46
    Why Didn't Darth Vader Use The Force To Heal His Wounds? | Star Wars Insider
    invidious
    122 views
    Thumbnail for Calling UNRWA a Proxy for Hamas is a 'Flat-Out Lie' | Quotable0:55
    Calling UNRWA a Proxy for Hamas is a 'Flat-Out Lie' | Quotable
    invidious
    119 views
    Thumbnail for Graphics Cards for $8?! | META PCs0:49
    Graphics Cards for $8?! | META PCs
    invidious
    115 views
    Thumbnail for 6 Times Science Proved It Can't Be Boring | BRIGHT SIDE9:23
    6 Times Science Proved It Can't Be Boring | BRIGHT SIDE
    invidious
    348 views
    Thumbnail for Paul Joseph Watson Says Western Civilization Is Dying8:06
    Paul Joseph Watson Says Western Civilization Is Dying
    AmericanRenaissance
    1510 views
    Thumbnail for Comedian Bill Burr Cake Analogy On Abortion0:59
    Comedian Bill Burr Cake Analogy On Abortion
    bestofpoal
    616 views
    Thumbnail for The Canuckistan Gun Grabber | Grunt Speak Shorts21:54
    The Canuckistan Gun Grabber | Grunt Speak Shorts
    Terrence Popp
    747 views
    Thumbnail for Save D.C. Daycare!1:08
    Save D.C. Daycare!
    IJvids
    917 views
    Thumbnail for The Lost History Of The Flat Earth16:14
    The Lost History Of The Flat Earth
    bestofsaidit
    718 views
    Thumbnail for "Don't wallow in hopelessness. Get active for our race."0:39
    "Don't wallow in hopelessness. Get active for our race."
    AOUisgay
    483 views
    Thumbnail for Jerome Tuccille: Rand, Rothbard and the LP's Big Moment4:51
    Jerome Tuccille: Rand, Rothbard and the LP's Big Moment
    ReasonVids
    858 views

points

Permalink
Reply
ij
,
institute for justice
,
freedom
,
liberty
,
individual rights
,
constitution
,
constitutional law
,
unconstitutional law
,
con law
,
constitutional litigation
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle