HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Nurse Practitioners Can Make Health Care Cheaper (and Doctors Want to Stop Them)

Views:996
@ReasonVids

"The major motivation in this opposition is kind of a turf war," says Dale Ann Dorsey, a nurse practitioner who runs her own women's health clinic in Scottsdale, Arizona.

Arizona is one of 18 states that allows nurse practitioners to run independent primary care practices, with full prescribing privileges, and without the oversight of a licensed physician. Earlier this year, nurse practitioners in California pushed to liberalize scope-of-practice rules in the Golden State, only to be stopped dead in their tracks by the powerful California Medical Association (CMA), which poured more than $1 million into lobbying efforts in the first half of 2013, when the legislation was under consideration.

"Nurse practioners' training is very limited compared to physicians," says Paul Phinney, a California pediatrician and former CMA president. "They lack a certain kind of experience that I believe is very important to the safety of patients and the quality of medical care that they're providing."

He has a point. Physicians are required to obtain far more education and clinical experience than are nurse practitioners. But there's little to no evidence showing that, when it comes to primary care, all of that extra education makes any difference in patient health outcomes. A 2012 Health Affairs survey of the medical literature found no difference in patient health between the two groups and even found a slightly higher satisfaction rate among patients of nurse practitioners.

So if outcomes are similar, and patients are satisfied, why are states like California hesitant to let more nurses open their own practices, especially when groups like the Association of American Medical Colleges are expecting a doctor shortage timebomb to detonate in the near future due to the aging population? Reason policy analyst Adam Summers says that concern for the public good is a secondary consideration at best in this case.

"Licensing laws are almost always sold as being in the public interest," says Summers. "But in reality all they do is drive up prices and reduce competition, which reduces the incentive to provide good services to the consumer."

Watch the video above to learn more about the nurse practitioners' struggle for clinical independence. Scroll down for downloadable links, and subscribe to Reason TV's Youtube channel for daily content like this.

Approximately 5 minutes. Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Shot by Tracy Oppenheimer and Weissmueller. Graphics by William Neff.

health care (issue)
,
nurse practitioner (occupation)
,
affordable healthcare
,
affordable healthcare act
,
obamacare
,
occupational licensing
,
competition
,
health care market
,
free market (idea)
,
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
doctors versus nurses
,
doctors vs. nurses
    Thumbnail for Officers on Trial in Killing of Kelly Thomas2:16
    Officers on Trial in Killing of Kelly Thomas
    ReasonVids
    1012 views
    Thumbnail for Balaji Srinivasan: Coronavirus Will Shape This Decade Like 9/11 Shaped the 2000s52:19
    Balaji Srinivasan: Coronavirus Will Shape This Decade Like 9/11 Shaped the 2000s
    ReasonVids
    952 views
    Thumbnail for Harvester's Advice1:17
    Harvester's Advice
    Queuenard
    524 views
    Thumbnail for Don't Be Afraid of Those 6,000 Felons Just Released From Prison - FAMM's Kevin Ring10:55
    Don't Be Afraid of Those 6,000 Felons Just Released From Prison - FAMM's Kevin Ring
    ReasonVids
    917 views
    Thumbnail for Koch LA Times Buyout Enrages Protesters: What We Saw at the "Save Our News" Rally4:29
    Koch LA Times Buyout Enrages Protesters: What We Saw at the "Save Our News" Rally
    ReasonVids
    864 views
    Thumbnail for Campaign for Liberty's Norm Singleton on Obamacare, Auditing the Fed, and the Libertarian Moment9:43
    Campaign for Liberty's Norm Singleton on Obamacare, Auditing the Fed, and the Libertarian Moment
    ReasonVids
    967 views
    Thumbnail for gnomes are real0:12
    gnomes are real
    AOUisgay
    364 views
    Thumbnail for Here's a dad who did a great job raising his daughter. 0:46
    Here's a dad who did a great job raising his daughter.
    bestofupgoat
    424 views
    Thumbnail for David Stockman on TARP, the Fed, Ron Paul and Reagan [FULL VERSION]42:06
    David Stockman on TARP, the Fed, Ron Paul and Reagan [FULL VERSION]
    ReasonVids
    979 views
    Thumbnail for Just needs more vodka0:17
    Just needs more vodka
    bestofupgoat
    132 views
    Thumbnail for CPAC: The Conservative Case for Criminal Justice Reform3:51
    CPAC: The Conservative Case for Criminal Justice Reform
    ReasonVids
    965 views
    Thumbnail for The Churchill Thrillers: An Interview with Michael and Patrick McMenamin3:06
    The Churchill Thrillers: An Interview with Michael and Patrick McMenamin
    ReasonVids
    855 views
    Thumbnail for German Newsreel 630. September 30, 194218:29
    German Newsreel 630. September 30, 1942
    NachtWaffen
    937 views
    Thumbnail for The Case for Pardoning Edward Snowden8:07
    The Case for Pardoning Edward Snowden
    ReasonVids
    900 views
    Thumbnail for PLT PARTY DRESSES TRY ON HAUL!! | Nadia katarina 8:22
    PLT PARTY DRESSES TRY ON HAUL!! | Nadia katarina
    invidious
    214 views
    Thumbnail for Advice you Bitches need to hear! 1:00
    Advice you Bitches need to hear!
    bestofupgoat
    161 views
    Thumbnail for Chris Bell: Kratom Is the Cure for the Opioid Epidemic25:21
    Chris Bell: Kratom Is the Cure for the Opioid Epidemic
    ReasonVids
    899 views
    Thumbnail for 이것 때문에 해운업계는 발등에 불이 떨어졌습니다/올트만 7조 달러 투자 계획/하락한 해운사, 조선의 국모가 보는 전망은?/죽어라 일해도 가난한 나라는 이것이 없다/최파고의부자되는법 | 삼프로TV_경제의신과함께5:48:01
    이것 때문에 해운업계는 발등에 불이 떨어졌습니다/올트만 7조 달러 투자 계획/하락한 해운사, 조선의 국모가 보는 전망은?/죽어라 일해도 가난한 나라는 이것이 없다/최파고의부자되는법 | 삼프로TV_경제의신과함께
    invidious
    304 views
    Thumbnail for NSF Funds Shamelessly Fraudulent Science. A half-million dollars couldn't find "white supremacy" in physics. No doubt, the National Science Foundation will just spend more.13:40
    NSF Funds Shamelessly Fraudulent Science. A half-million dollars couldn't find "white supremacy" in physics. No doubt, the National Science Foundation will just spend more.
    bestofsaidit
    935 views
    Thumbnail for What We Saw: National School Choice Week Kick-Off, New Orleans5:23
    What We Saw: National School Choice Week Kick-Off, New Orleans
    ReasonVids
    853 views
    Thumbnail for Libertarian Dad Jokes2:53
    Libertarian Dad Jokes
    ReasonVids
    758 views
    Thumbnail for Open Borders vs. COVID-19: A Soho Forum Debate1:25:37
    Open Borders vs. COVID-19: A Soho Forum Debate
    ReasonVids
    838 views
    Thumbnail for ‘Apple Could Never Make Anything as Shitty as the Things I Make:’ Artist Tom Sachs17:34
    ‘Apple Could Never Make Anything as Shitty as the Things I Make:’ Artist Tom Sachs
    ReasonVids
    909 views
    Thumbnail for Chameleon Changing Colors0:45
    Chameleon Changing Colors
    bestofvoatxyz
    730 views
    Thumbnail for A Joe Biden (War On) Christmas1:37
    A Joe Biden (War On) Christmas
    ReasonVids
    869 views

points

Permalink
Reply
health care (issue)
,
nurse practitioner (occupation)
,
affordable healthcare
,
affordable healthcare act
,
obamacare
,
occupational licensing
,
competition
,
health care market
,
free market (idea)
,
libertarian
,
reason magazine
,
doctors versus nurses
,
doctors vs. nurses
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle