HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

Net Neutrality, Title II Proponents "Assume Nothing Has Changed" Since 1995: Daniel Berninger

Views:897
@ReasonVids

"All the logic that we are seeing in the Net Neutrality debate is assuming that nothing has changed; it's assuming that it's 1995. What's actually happened is that people get more and more service, year in and year out," says Daniel Berninger, a telecom activist who was involved in the early days of internet-phone service of Vonage.

Net Neutrality proponents, including President Obama, argue that internet-service providers (ISPs) need to be regulated by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in order to keep the internet "free and open."

Berninger heads up VCXC, a nonprofit that is pushing for regulatory and policy changes to speed up the transition to IP-based networks for voice and data sharing. He's an unsparing critic of FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler's plan to implement Net Neutrality by regulating broadband network operators under Title II or "common carrier" provisions of federal law.

Title II has historically applied to telephone companies, which were regulated as public utilities and subject to government scrutiny regarding every aspect of service, including pricing and universal service obligations. Since the mid-1990s, the internet has been classified as an "information service," which is subject to much less regulation under Title I of the relevant federal law.

"Title II regulation has been around for 80 years," says Berninger, "and we know exactly what it can accomplish and what it can't accomplish...in all the things that it touched, it essentially destroyed innovation." In 1956, he explains, as part of a consent decree involving ATT, phone service was regulated by the FCC under Title II while "information services" were essentially unregulated. "We split communications and computing and treated them entirely different—essentially as a twin experiment. Well, one twin prospered and one twin did not do very well." Berninger argues that virtually all the problems that proponents of Title II regulation and Net Neutrality worry over—such as the blocking of specific websites and the deliberate slowing of traffic—haven't occurred precisely because ISPs are subject to market competition and must constantly innovate to keep customers happy. FCC regulation would hamper that.

The FCC will vote on Wheeler's proposal later this week and is widely expected to endorse it. The FCC has lost two previous attempts to assert regulatory control over the internet.

More Reason on Net Neutrality here - http://reason.com/tags/net-neutrality

Read the FCC's own report on Internet Access Services, which supports Berninger's claim that service and speeds have been increasing over the past several decades.

About 11 minutes.

Camera by Joshua Swain and Robert Mariani. Edited by Mariani.

Go to Reason.tv for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel to get automatic notifications when new material goes live.

net neutrality
,
politics (tv genre)
,
reason (magazine)
,
nick gillespie (author)
,
fcc
,
u.s. federal communications commission (government agency)
,
title ii
    Thumbnail for 3-D Printing DNA: Hacking Life's Code and Creating New Organisms10:33
    3-D Printing DNA: Hacking Life's Code and Creating New Organisms
    ReasonVids
    828 views
    Thumbnail for Americans Believe Most Politicians Abuse Their Power: Reason-Rupe Poll April 20141:18
    Americans Believe Most Politicians Abuse Their Power: Reason-Rupe Poll April 2014
    ReasonVids
    962 views
    Thumbnail for Reason and Science Make Us Moral: Michael Shermer on "The Moral Arc"20:46
    Reason and Science Make Us Moral: Michael Shermer on "The Moral Arc"
    ReasonVids
    897 views
    Thumbnail for Putin busting some moves2:07
    Putin busting some moves
    Gviduser
    459 views
    Thumbnail for Morticians Association of America Endorses President Obama's Tough New Fuel Efficiency Standards1:14
    Morticians Association of America Endorses President Obama's Tough New Fuel Efficiency Standards
    ReasonVids
    973 views
    Thumbnail for Is Abortion a Constitutional Right? Josh Blackman on Alito's Draft54:23
    Is Abortion a Constitutional Right? Josh Blackman on Alito's Draft
    ReasonVids
    806 views
    Thumbnail for tnt weapons in 2012 vs now | Alexa Real1:13
    tnt weapons in 2012 vs now | Alexa Real
    invidious
    290 views
    Thumbnail for Brakes broke0:11
    Brakes broke
    bestofnab
    2267 views
    Thumbnail for Pension Tsunami's Jack Dean on the Growing Wave of Public Pension Debt9:48
    Pension Tsunami's Jack Dean on the Growing Wave of Public Pension Debt
    ReasonVids
    943 views
    Thumbnail for Remy: I Saw Daddy Pat Down Santa Claus (A Very TSA Christmas Song)1:14
    Remy: I Saw Daddy Pat Down Santa Claus (A Very TSA Christmas Song)
    ReasonVids
    869 views
    Thumbnail for John McCain, the Senate's Most Influential Hawk, Is Dead5:53
    John McCain, the Senate's Most Influential Hawk, Is Dead
    ReasonVids
    1015 views
    Thumbnail for Subterranean tunnel jews have riddled the ground beneath our feet. 0:06
    Subterranean tunnel jews have riddled the ground beneath our feet.
    bestofupgoat
    463 views
    Thumbnail for 3D-printed AK47 buckshot rounds for drone defense0:19
    3D-printed AK47 buckshot rounds for drone defense
    bestofupgoat
    85 views
    Thumbnail for We Are As Gods: Stewart Brand & The Fight to Bring Back Extinct Species6:11
    We Are As Gods: Stewart Brand & The Fight to Bring Back Extinct Species
    ReasonVids
    916 views
    Thumbnail for French farmers blockade Paris over banker's attempts to destroy their businesses.  That's a lot of fucking tractors.9:12
    French farmers blockade Paris over banker's attempts to destroy their businesses. That's a lot of fucking tractors.
    bestofupgoat
    423 views
    Thumbnail for Arnold's Last Stand: How the Lame-Duck Governor Is Fighting for One Last Win Over Unions6:10
    Arnold's Last Stand: How the Lame-Duck Governor Is Fighting for One Last Win Over Unions
    ReasonVids
    895 views
    Thumbnail for Wind turbines...Intermittent, wasteful, toxic. Perfect for the dystopian climate scam agenda 2030. Which every hardworking person pays for...1:02
    Wind turbines...Intermittent, wasteful, toxic. Perfect for the dystopian climate scam agenda 2030. Which every hardworking person pays for...
    AOUisgay
    537 views
    Thumbnail for Ladies, We're Screwed: Why Obama's Re-election is Bad for Choice2:17
    Ladies, We're Screwed: Why Obama's Re-election is Bad for Choice
    ReasonVids
    896 views
    Thumbnail for Ireland's Honor Badge! 🎖 #usa #israel #palestine #uk #ireland #politics #congress #news #canada | Breezy Politics0:52
    Ireland's Honor Badge! 🎖 #usa #israel #palestine #uk #ireland #politics #congress #news #canada | Breezy Politics
    invidious
    109 views
    Thumbnail for Japs create "steak" made from sewage.0:40
    Japs create "steak" made from sewage.
    bestofupgoat
    403 views
    Thumbnail for Richard Viguerie on the Future of Conservatism7:34
    Richard Viguerie on the Future of Conservatism
    ReasonVids
    806 views
    Thumbnail for Chicken Shawarma For Weight Loss v.2 | The Golden Balance1:05
    Chicken Shawarma For Weight Loss v.2 | The Golden Balance
    invidious
    58 views
    Thumbnail for Denial: 25 Years Without a Soul - Q/A with Jonathan Rauch9:54
    Denial: 25 Years Without a Soul - Q/A with Jonathan Rauch
    ReasonVids
    992 views
    Thumbnail for Gov't to makeup artists:  Put down the blush, or we'll shut you DOWN2:51
    Gov't to makeup artists: Put down the blush, or we'll shut you DOWN
    IJvids
    870 views
    Thumbnail for @the_old_ones tries to get buff for the ladies0:10
    @the_old_ones tries to get buff for the ladies
    bestofupgoat
    456 views

points

Permalink
Reply
net neutrality
,
politics (tv genre)
,
reason (magazine)
,
nick gillespie (author)
,
fcc
,
u.s. federal communications commission (government agency)
,
title ii
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle