HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle
Expand

The GOP Is Wrong About Sanctuary Cities

Views:939
@ReasonVids

"We have to end this sanctuary cities crap FAST!" says Donald Trump, the billionaire seeking the Republican Party's presidential nomination.

Trump, who rarely misses an opportunity to inveigh against both legal and illegal immigrants, has been joined in his condemnation of "sanctuary cities" by many of his GOP rivals.

Sanctuary cities—there are more than 200 across the United States—instruct local law enforcement officials to not investigate the immigration status of suspects or prisoners in their custody. The thinking is that such restraint will make victims and witnesses more likely to help police.

Again and again, Trump points to the murder of Kate Steinle in San Francisco by an illegal immigrant from Mexico to prove his point that sanctuary cities are out of control, dangerous, and lawless. Starting in the late 1980s, elected officials in San Francisco and other cities changed police protocols in a bid to increase cooperation with local residents, many of whom might have been illegal.

Defenders of sanctuary cities say Trump and other critics are rank opportunists with no knowledge of stopping crime and protecting public safety.

"Over the past 25 years, the city and county of San Francisco has been very sensitive to the question of immigration and to the plight of undocumented peoples," says Ross Mirkarimi, the San Francisco County Sheriff who oversees the jail system that released Steinle's alleged killer, Juan Francisco Lopez-Sanchez. Prior to Steinle's death from a ricoheting bullet, the federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) had requested that the county turn Lopez-Sanchez over to them for deportation. But Mirkarimi says that under San Francisco's 1989 "City and County of Refuge" law and its 2013 "Due Process for All" law, ICE needed to supply him with a court order to take custody. Had the agency done so, he would have "happily" complied with the request. In fact, he tells Reason TV that he does so on a regular basis.

In general, first-generation immigrants, whether in the country illegally or not, commit fewer violent and property crimes than either second-generation or native-born citizens. And there's scant evidence that San Francisco is more dangerous than non-sanctuary cities of a similar size. In fact, its murder rate is about one-third that of non-sanctuary Indianapolis.

But this line of argument doesn't hold for some anti-immigration activists, such as Don Rosenberg, who started writing about the danger of unlicensed drivers after an illegal immigrant ran over his son in a car and killed him.

"Even if it was true that illegal aliens committed less crime than citizens, every crime that they commit is an additional crime that didn't have to happen," says Rosenberg.

Cutting off the flow of new people and reducing the population via mass deportations might reduce the overall number of crimes, but the expense of doing so would be overwhelming, as would the incursions on the civil liberties of all Americans, who would need to get used to showing citizenship papers at routine traffic stops and submitting to a costly and invasive "E-verify" system every time they try to get a new job or hire a new employee.

"To just point the finger at sanctuary cities...because of this tragedy may feel good in venting," says Mirkarimi of Kate Steinle's death. "But it's only going to unravel the good work that is being done to build the kind of trust that needs to be built with these communities in the first place."

About 5 minutes. Produced by Zach Weissmueller. Shot by Paul Detrick and Weissmueller. Music by Chris Zabriskie.

Scroll down for downloadable versions. Subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel for daily content like this.

sanctuary city
,
immigration (quotation subject)
,
u.s. immigration and customs enforcement (government agency)
,
illegal immigration
,
illegals
,
kate steinle
,
san francisco
,
donald trump
,
gop
,
republicans
,
republican presidential race 2016
,
libertarian
,
reason magazine
    Thumbnail for Dilbert Creator Scott Adams on Donald Trump's "Linguistic Kill Shots"8:00
    Dilbert Creator Scott Adams on Donald Trump's "Linguistic Kill Shots"
    ReasonVids
    1074 views
    Thumbnail for Hate Stalks Stanford9:37
    Hate Stalks Stanford
    AmericanRenaissance
    924 views
    Thumbnail for Farmers in France exercising a new method of protest by spraying manure at government offices.0:35
    Farmers in France exercising a new method of protest by spraying manure at government offices.
    bestofupgoat
    406 views
    Thumbnail for "Dream Team"0:24
    "Dream Team"
    AOUisgay
    457 views
    Thumbnail for Is Obama to Blame for Syria's Disaster? "ISIS: Inside the Army of Terror" co-author Michael Weiss11:32
    Is Obama to Blame for Syria's Disaster? "ISIS: Inside the Army of Terror" co-author Michael Weiss
    ReasonVids
    940 views
    Thumbnail for A fishing trip that they'll never forget 1:24
    A fishing trip that they'll never forget
    bestofvoatxyz
    807 views
    Thumbnail for The "Lunkhead Alarm" at Planet Fitness | Grunt Speak Highlights4:27
    The "Lunkhead Alarm" at Planet Fitness | Grunt Speak Highlights
    Terrence Popp
    1233 views
    Thumbnail for "Kontra 24" με τον Μάριο Αραβαντινό και τη Λουκία Γκάτσου 11 Νοε.2024 | Kontra Channel1:56:28
    "Kontra 24" με τον Μάριο Αραβαντινό και τη Λουκία Γκάτσου 11 Νοε.2024 | Kontra Channel
    invidious
    133 views
    Thumbnail for Tucker Carlson on Sarah Palin0:39
    Tucker Carlson on Sarah Palin
    ReasonVids
    1001 views
    Thumbnail for RESTful APIs in 100 Seconds // Build an API from Scratch with Node.js Express | Fireship11:20
    RESTful APIs in 100 Seconds // Build an API from Scratch with Node.js Express | Fireship
    invidious
    326 views
    Thumbnail for How to Grow A City in Honduras, Part III: The Skeptics6:17
    How to Grow A City in Honduras, Part III: The Skeptics
    ReasonVids
    954 views
    Thumbnail for Odin's ravens destroy Israeli flags.2:19
    Odin's ravens destroy Israeli flags.
    AOUisgay
    549 views
    Thumbnail for French Motorcycles0:07
    French Motorcycles
    bestofvoatxyz
    568 views
    Thumbnail for The Truth About "Three Month Courtship" | Grunt Speak Live2:09:56
    The Truth About "Three Month Courtship" | Grunt Speak Live
    Terrence Popp
    1538 views
    Thumbnail for Attack Ads, Circa 18001:43
    Attack Ads, Circa 1800
    ReasonVids
    990 views
    Thumbnail for Funny Scotsman Trying To Say " Purple Burglar Alarm " | Staale Rosoe0:21
    Funny Scotsman Trying To Say " Purple Burglar Alarm " | Staale Rosoe
    invidious
    383 views
    Thumbnail for This life hack will get this idiot around a tree | FunnyMemeSpot0:09
    This life hack will get this idiot around a tree | FunnyMemeSpot
    invidious
    268 views
    Thumbnail for Watch as the Texas White girl absolutely annihilates the myth of black athletic supremacy0:23
    Watch as the Texas White girl absolutely annihilates the myth of black athletic supremacy
    AOUisgay
    905 views
    Thumbnail for Here’s the video of every celebrity without a mask during the Super Bowl. But every kid in California will have to be wearing them tomorrow in school. They must all be holding their breaths the entire game.0:28
    Here’s the video of every celebrity without a mask during the Super Bowl. But every kid in California will have to be wearing them tomorrow in school. They must all be holding their breaths the entire game.
    bestofpoal
    992 views
    Thumbnail for Stossel: Venezuela IS Socialism4:52
    Stossel: Venezuela IS Socialism
    ReasonVids
    860 views

points

Permalink
Reply
sanctuary city
,
immigration (quotation subject)
,
u.s. immigration and customs enforcement (government agency)
,
illegal immigration
,
illegals
,
kate steinle
,
san francisco
,
donald trump
,
gop
,
republicans
,
republican presidential race 2016
,
libertarian
,
reason magazine
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle