HomeUploadUpload DirectHotlinkRandomAbouttheme toggle

Amish vs. the Courts: Family Speaks Out on Fleeing the U.S. to Escape Court-Mandated Chemo

Views: 856
Disclaimer: ReasonTV visited the Hershbergers in Homerville, Ohio. Amish law precludes formal interview settings, but the Hershbergers spoke with ReasonTV at length about Sarah's case and allowed us to record them.

For nearly a year, 11-year-old Sarah Hershberger has simultaneously been battling cancer and a court case. Last April, she was diagnosed with lymphoblastic lymphoma, a rare cancer. Her doctor encouraged her to immediately start chemotherapy, and she quickly began her first treatment.

The side effects took their toll, and the Hershbergers feared for Sarah's well-being. They decided to discontinue treatment. "The chemotherapy was really good, but stopping at that point was the best investment we did," says Andy Hershberger, Sarah's father.

"We were pretty sure we were going to lose her if we kept doing the chemo," says Anna Hershberger, Sarah's mother. The Hershbergers wanted to pursue a more natural treatment, then return to the chemotherapy if necessary.

Akron Children's Hospital was not open to discussing alternative or supplemental treatments, and officials there expressed concern that Sarah would die if she discontinued treatment. The hospital eventually went on the offensive.

"Akron Children's Hospital originally tried to have Sarah Hershberger taken away from her parents and Medina County Children Services flat out refused to do that. They said these parents are suitable parents, they are high quality parents, they're loving parents," says the Hershbergers attorney, Maurice Thompson.

The hospital continued to push the issue all the way to an appellate court, arguing that "A finding of parental 'suitability' does not end a probate court's inquiry. Parental rights, even if based upon firm belief and honest convictions can be limited in order to protect the 'best interests' of the child."

The appellate court sided with the hospital and appointed a legal guardian to make medical decisions for Sarah. The Hershbergers feared that the guardian would force Sarah back into chemotherapy, so they fled the country.

"We were in Mexico three weeks," says Sarah's uncle, Isaac Hershberger. "We had to leave because if we stayed in the U.S., any hospital in the U.S. would report right back to Akron Children's".

The Hershbergers didn't provide specifics about Sarah's "alternative" treatment, but she seems to be doing well. She may be feeling better because of the first chemotherapy treatment, or the alternative treatment, or a combination. We don't know what Sarah's future holds, but Thompson says that because the family is more than suitable, Sarah's treatment should be left entirely to their discretion.

"Having a free society means that people need to be free to take risks, including risks with their family when they are suitable and loving parents who will take those risks out of a position of love and belief," says Thompson. "It's one thing for society, government, for experts to overrule parents who are abusive, or who are neglectful or who perhaps lack the capacity to properly care for their children, and it's imperative to emphasize that none of those are the case here.

"If we could just be left alone, that's what we're asking for," says Isaac Hershberger.

It appears that this request will be fulfilled. The appellate judge recently accepted the guardian's resignation, and it looks like the Hershbergers will not have to continue this court battle. If they do, Thompson is ready to fight the "best interest of the child" standard all the way to the Supreme Court.

"Whether it's the right to refuse unwanted forced medical treatment, or whether it's the fundamental right that guarantees you to raise and bring up your child in terms of their education and their health care in the way that you see fit as a parent, it's pretty clear that the Hershbergers have strong constitutional rights that are at stake here. And that's really what we're protecting," Thompson says.

About 6:30 minutes.

Written and produced by Tracy Oppenheimer, who also narrates. Camera by Josh Swain and Amanda Winkler.

Featuring "Syaba" from Ryosuke Sone's Root of Sorrow.

Scroll down for downloadable versions, and subscribe to ReasonTV's YouTube Channel for notifications when new material goes live.
@ReasonVidsfollow
Thumbnail for Can Muslims be Free Marketeers?14:36
Can Muslims be Free Marketeers?
ReasonVids
831 views
Thumbnail for PoS cop punches and chokes teen girl0:49
PoS cop punches and chokes teen girl
publicfreakouts
633 views
Thumbnail for imposter0:18
imposter
bestofupgoat
110 views
Thumbnail for Biden stumbles and falls on the stairs of Air Force One.0:30
Biden stumbles and falls on the stairs of Air Force One.
AOU
1705 views
Thumbnail for The Last Stand of Implicit Whiteness18:05
The Last Stand of Implicit Whiteness
murdochmurdoch
1418 views
Thumbnail for Joe Rogan sees only "Young White Kids" Looting Sneakers, when videos clearly show Blacks on Blacks on Blacks10:43
Joe Rogan sees only "Young White Kids" Looting Sneakers, when videos clearly show Blacks on Blacks on Blacks
AOU
904 views
Thumbnail for IJ Client Zaher El-Ali Challenges Texas' Seizure of His Chevy Silverado - Ali Committed No Crime2:41
IJ Client Zaher El-Ali Challenges Texas' Seizure of His Chevy Silverado - Ali Committed No Crime
IJvids
946 views
Thumbnail for HAVE YOU HEARD OF CANADA'S EPSTEIN ISLAND?3:39
HAVE YOU HEARD OF CANADA'S EPSTEIN ISLAND?
bestofupgoat
424 views
Thumbnail for Democrat Convention 2008 Day Four5:25
Democrat Convention 2008 Day Four
ReasonVids
821 views
Thumbnail for Tweeting Around Egypt's Web Blackout: Meet John Scott-Railton4:51
Tweeting Around Egypt's Web Blackout: Meet John Scott-Railton
ReasonVids
890 views
Thumbnail for Is the Tea Party Movement Racist?2:14
Is the Tea Party Movement Racist?
ReasonVids
895 views
Thumbnail for Collective Bargaining and the Bottom Line: Q&A with Heritage Foundation's James Sherk5:36
Collective Bargaining and the Bottom Line: Q&A with Heritage Foundation's James Sherk
ReasonVids
883 views
Thumbnail for Black Lives Matter: Hysteria and Lies12:04
Black Lives Matter: Hysteria and Lies
AmericanRenaissance
1356 views
Thumbnail for 'Warlords Will Take Over' and Other Lines Libertarians Are Tired of Hearing3:00
'Warlords Will Take Over' and Other Lines Libertarians Are Tired of Hearing
ReasonVids
892 views
Thumbnail for Men Don’t Have Reproductive Rights | Grunt Speak Shorts13:53
Men Don’t Have Reproductive Rights | Grunt Speak Shorts
Terrence Popp
724 views
Thumbnail for Mountain Lion Captured on Ring Camera in Billings, Montana0:24
Mountain Lion Captured on Ring Camera in Billings, Montana
bestofvoatxyz
782 views
Thumbnail for Whole Foods CEO John Mackey on The Moral Case for Capitalism6:37
Whole Foods CEO John Mackey on The Moral Case for Capitalism
ReasonVids
793 views
Thumbnail for Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!1:41
Introducing Reason's 2009 Webathon! Because Free Minds and Free Markets Aren't Free!
ReasonVids
750 views
Thumbnail for "Restore the Fourth Rally" Against NSA Surveillance2:34
"Restore the Fourth Rally" Against NSA Surveillance
ReasonVids
890 views
Thumbnail for Pork Party House: Where DC insiders go for taxpayer-subsidized fun6:24
Pork Party House: Where DC insiders go for taxpayer-subsidized fun
ReasonVids
956 views
Thumbnail for If You Think Your State is Broke Now, Just Wait Til The Pension Bomb Explodes!0:23
If You Think Your State is Broke Now, Just Wait Til The Pension Bomb Explodes!
ReasonVids
917 views

points

Permalink
Reply
amish (ethnicity), cancer, chemotherapy, courts, court-mandated treatment, parental rights, ohio, akron, reasontv
TOS  •  Add Keywords  •  Donate  •   Analytics  •   DMCA  •   Puzzle